Book review of the Second Worst Restaurant in France by PumpjackPiddlewick

In my search for books on or based in France, I was curiously surprised to find a book by Alexander McCall Smith. He of the No.1 Ladies Detective Agency fame. But the title intrigued me, The Second Worst Restaurant in France*.

I have read some of McCall Smith’s detective agency series, which are set in Botswana. His No. 44 selection, set in Scotland, is even better, to my mind. So curiosity abounded to find a book set in France.

Quirky Concept

The unique thing about McCall Smith is his eclectic spirit. You never quite know where he is going with his stories. They wrap the every day around a quirky focus. And the Second Worst Restaurant in France doesn’t disappoint. Heck, the title could have told you that. And the reason I for one felt a need to read it. (A prime example of title as click-bait.)

And luckily, the read of the book didn’t disappoint either.

The main character is rather dull, the steady hand at the tiller as we navigate through the story. He does pick up a bit as the book builds in interest and he begins to find his feet. But he makes a nice foil to the other collection of characters. Almost all burst on the scene is some interesting, quirky or emotional moment.

The Second Worst Restaurant in France isn’t so much about food, or eating, as about spirit of goodwill and helpfulness. And honestly, the story could almost be set anywhere, except the focus of the French and their passion for food does centre it well. It would not read so well or be so believable if it were, say, the second worst restaurant in Holland, in example.

In quick synopsis

Paul Stewart is a food book writer who is struggling with the book he is currently writing. Thanks to his cousin Chloe, he ends up in France and the village they are staying in boasts it has the second worst restaurant in France. Certainly not the worst. That is… somewhere else.

Very quickly the village life and its cast of characters sucks him in to their lives and problems. Next thing you know he is helping out at the restaurant and wondering if he can help make it better.

A truly eclectic, and quirky, read. In true McCall Smith style. And also fun. By the end I found I enjoyed this book of his most of all.

From the USA:

From the UK:

*Our Book Club Disclosure

For our Vive le Livre Book Club we are affiliated* with Bookshop.Org. As great readers ourselves, we wanted to offer a way to purchase the books we recommend about France and the French (and wine). We specifically chose to affiliate with Bookshop because they support independent bookshops. They are currently supporting, and you can buy from, bookshops in the UK, USA and Spain.

From the USA:

From the UK:

I also offer a small selection of vintage book finds, mostly English, some French in my own Shop.

*If you would like to read more about Affiliates, or be more involved, visit the Nourishing Pumpjack & Piddlewick page.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.